Atlantic Beach, nestled at the gateway to Long Island’s south shore, is known for its breezy boardwalks, golden sand, and laid-back vibe. But beyond the sun and surf, this Hempstead neighborhood boasts a food scene that’s a genuine local treasure. Whether you’re in flip-flops or out for a date night, Atlantic Beach’s culinary offerings reflect both its oceanside location and its welcoming community spirit. Here’s your insider’s guide to savoring the best of this coastal enclave—from casual taquerias to elegant seafood suppers, cozy bakeries, and everything in between.
The Seafood Stars: Oceanfront Dining with a View
It’s hard to think of Atlantic Beach without picturing a plate of fresh seafood enjoyed steps from the shore. The most iconic destination is The Sands Beach Club Restaurant, situated right on the Atlantic promenade near Ocean Boulevard. Their lobster rolls, buttery-soft and served on toasted potato buns, are the stuff of local legend. For sunset dinners, nothing beats the open-air deck—order the grilled swordfish with lemon-caper sauce and watch the sky streak pink over the waves.
If you’re craving clams or oysters, Gino’s Beach Shack at Magnolia Boulevard is a must. This casual spot—half beach hut, half raw bar—serves shellfish shucked to order and the crispiest fried calamari baskets on the barrier island. It’s the ultimate lunch stop when you want something unfussy, salty, and utterly fresh.
Price range: $20–$40 per entrée (The Sands); $12–$25 (Gino’s Beach Shack)
Family Classics and Pizza Perfection
Just a block north, Atlantic Boulevard is home to a tight cluster of casual favorites, anchored by Atlantic Beach Pizza. This neighborhood pizzeria has been tossing dough for decades, and their signature “Boardwalk Pie”—with sweet tomato, fresh mozzarella, and just a kiss of sea salt—is as comforting as a beach blanket on a cool night. Loyalists swear by the classic pepperoni and the loaded veggie.
Next door, you’ll find La Strada Trattoria, an inviting Italian spot with brick-oven specialties. Their penne alla vodka is creamy and rich while still being light enough for a summer night. On weekends, the patio buzzes with families lingering over cannoli and espresso.
Price range: $4–$5 per slice, $18–$22 for whole pies (Atlantic Beach Pizza); $15–$30 for pasta and mains (La Strada Trattoria)
Sweet Surprises: Bakeries and Cafés
For those with a sweet tooth, Sweet Tide Bakehouse at the corner of Park Street and Atlantic Place is essential. This small but mighty bakery is famous for their sea salt chocolate chip cookies—chewy, gooey, and with just enough crunch. On weekends, folks line up for cinnamon rolls and lemon glazed scones, so get there early.
*Caffeine cravings?* Sunset Bean Café, just a block from the boardwalk on Pacific Boulevard, is a trendy local favorite. Their cold brew is top-notch, and they serve inventive daily specials—think honey lavender lattes and pistachio croissants. It’s the kind of place where you’ll spot neighbors working on their laptops or friends meeting up before a beach walk.
Price range: $2–$6 per pastry; coffee and espresso drinks $3–$7
Hidden Gems and Local Traditions
No foodie tour of Atlantic Beach would be complete without tracking down a couple of true neighborhood secrets. Around the intersection of Beach 33rd Street and Bay Boulevard, you’ll find Mar y Sol Taqueria, a cheerful food truck that rolls up on sunny afternoons. Their fish tacos, generously loaded and vibrant with lime and cilantro, are beloved by locals. The elote (Mexican street corn) is smoky, sweet, and messy in the best way.
Just a few streets away, Family Deli & Grill is a classic New York-style corner deli and sandwich stop tucked beside a residential block. It’s the go-to for overflowing breakfast sandwiches, lunchtime heroes, and freshly made salads. The egg sandwich with chorizo and avocado, served on a pillowy Kaiser roll, is the neighborhood’s worst-kept secret.
Price range: $9–$16 for sandwiches/tacos (Mar y Sol Taqueria); $5–$10 for breakfast/lunch specials (Family Deli & Grill)
Special Nights Out: Elegant Eats
For a special occasion, The Atlantic House on Beach 20th Street offers fine dining without pretense. Reserve a window seat and start with the shellfish tower or grilled octopus. Their pan-seared scallops with saffron risotto have earned glowing reviews all over Nassau County. The wine list is thoughtfully curated, mostly featuring crisp whites and rosés that sing with seafood dishes.
Locals also celebrate milestones at Coastal Tap & Table, a bistro on the main drag known for its creative seasonal menus. You’ll find dishes like pan-roasted duck breast with cherry gastrique and local striped bass with grilled asparagus. The small plates—especially the roasted peach burrata—are not to be missed.
Price range: $22–$45 entrees (The Atlantic House); $15–$36 for small and large plates (Coastal Tap & Table)
Where to Savor It All
The heart of Atlantic Beach’s food scene stretches between Atlantic Boulevard and the boardwalk, with sweet surprises and savory standouts a short stroll apart. The neighborhood’s year-round residents and summer visitors mingle over slices, seafood, and café treats, keeping the vibe lively but always warm.
Want to enjoy it all? Plan a food crawl: start with coffee at Sunset Bean Café, grab lunch at Gino’s Beach Shack, snack on cookies from Sweet Tide Bakehouse, then cap off your night with dinner at The Atlantic House and a stroll by the ocean.
Conclusion
Atlantic Beach packs a culinary punch that’s as welcoming and varied as its community. Whether you’re after sunrise pastries, classic clam shacks, upscale seafood, or the ultimate slice of pizza, this Long Island gem invites you to eat like a local. So grab your friends, bring your appetite, and let Atlantic Beach’s food scene surprise you—one delicious bite at a time.